{"id":11678,"date":"2021-11-23T19:55:42","date_gmt":"2021-11-23T19:55:42","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/lavozlit.com\/?p=11678"},"modified":"2021-11-23T19:55:42","modified_gmt":"2021-11-23T19:55:42","slug":"end-criminal-charges-for-miscarriages","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/2021\/11\/23\/end-criminal-charges-for-miscarriages\/","title":{"rendered":"End criminal charges for miscarriages!"},"content":{"rendered":"

Republished from Socialist Resurgence’s website<\/span><\/a><\/span><\/strong><\/p>\n


\n<\/strong>By ERWIN FREED<\/strong>
\nBrittney Poolaw, a 21-year-old Indigenous woman, is the most recent high-profile victim of anti-women reproductive policies in the United States. In October, Poolaw was convicted by the state of Oklahoma on charges of first-degree manslaughter with a sentence of four years in prison. The \u201ccrime\u201d was having a miscarriage in her fourth month of pregnancy at the age of 19 in January 2020.\u00a0According to Oxygen News<\/em>, 57 women have been arrested<\/span><\/a> for miscarriage in Oklahoma and over 1200 in the United States since 2006.
\nControlling bodies<\/strong>
\nCapitalism demands that the ruling class have as close to absolute control over working people\u2019s bodies and lives as possible. That entails strict policing by the state of reproductive capacities, especially for women and queer people. Laws criminalizing miscarriage and stillbirth\u00a0 (a pregnancy terminated after 20 weeks) are especially sharp demonstrations of this fact.
\nPlanned Parenthood explains<\/a><\/span> that \u201c1 in 4 pregnancies ends in miscarriage before 20 weeks. Many people miscarry before they even know they are pregnant. The most common causes of miscarriage are immune system issues, hormonal abnormalities, clotting problems, medical conditions (polycystic ovarian syndrome, diabetes, thyroid issues, etc.), womb or cervix issues, chromosomal abnormalities, and severe infections that lead to high fever. In most cases, the pregnant person did absolutely nothing to cause the miscarriage.\u201dnIn fact, up to 50% of all pregnancies may end in miscarriage.
\nA legal framework has been constructed by U.S. capitalism that faults pregnant people for miscarriages and stillbirths. Thirty-eight states have so-called \u201cfetal harm\u201d laws on the books that create special charges on the premise that a fetus is a \u201cperson.\u201d Of these, at least eight allow for prosecuting the pregnant person for \u201cfetal homicide.\u201d Similarly, a 2014 article in the Indiana Law Journal<\/a><\/span> remarks that 17 states \u201cconsider substance abuse during pregnancy child\u00a0abuse for purposes of their civil child welfare statutes, and four states \u2026 consider it grounds for civil commitment. Additionally, when drug abuse is suspected, several states require\u00a0health professionals to report to the state, test for prenatal drug exposure, or both.
\nAll of these laws are a direct product of the immense expansion of the prison industrial complex begun in the 1960s and accelerated through the next decades. Often, the original justifications for \u201cfetal assault\u201d laws were supposedly to bring greater retribution to men who attacked women\u2014especially in cases of domestic violence\u2014but they have quickly been turned into their opposite, providing legal grounds for criminalizing pregnancy.
\nOne particularly well known victim of these statutes is Bei Bei Shuai<\/span><\/a>, a Chinese immigrant who spent more than 420 days in an Indiana jail for having a stillbirth with a \u201cmassive brain hemorrhage\u201d in 2010 following a suicide attempt. According to the above mentioned law journal article, \u201cNo individual who has survived a recent suicide attempt has been threatened\u00a0with possible criminal penalties greater than those faced by \u2026 Bei Bei Shuai.\u201d Laws criminalizing suicide attempts have been virtually totally eliminated due to a common understanding that they make an already bad situation worse from both a personal and public health standpoint.
\nWhile the state prosecutes pregnant people for \u201cendangering\u201d themselves and\/or the fetus they carry, the number one cause of death among pregnant women (statistics do not appear to be available for pregnant people generally) is murder. Femicide is a major problem everywhere in the world and is exacerbated in the United States by the conditions of extreme poverty and dependence on support networks which often contain abusive men, partners or otherwise. This system is enforced by the state\u2019s material emphasis on the nuclear family.
\nDanger to all<\/strong>
\n\u201c[T]he nation\u2019s leading medical associations, including the American Medical Association, the\u00a0American Academy of Pediatrics, and the American Public Health Association, have all\u00a0opposed punitive measures against pregnant women who use drugs. Their opposition is due\u00a0in part to their understanding that such measures will deter women from accessing much\u00a0needed prenatal care and that the absence of such care certainly will have deleterious\u00a0consequences for both maternal and fetal health\u201d (April L. Cherry, \u201cThe Detention, Confinement, and Incarceration of Pregnant Women for the Benefit of Fetal Health,\u201d 2007).
\nFetal personhood laws are another side of the general attack on reproductive rights that connects strictly \u201cbiological\u201d definitions of gender<\/a><\/span> and the ongoing rollback of abortion access<\/span><\/a>. All of these government policies result from the anti-women and anti-queer dynamics that capitalism generates and upholds. There is no permanent solution for reproductive justice under this system.
\nThe criminalization of pregnancy places the \u201clife\u201d of a fetus\u2014or even embryo\u2014above that of the person carrying it. In this reactionary model, a pregnant person\u2014viewed exclusively as a cis woman\u2014has the exclusive duty of protecting their potential offspring. All external factors\u2014e.g., environmental toxicity, stress from working while pregnant, systemic racism, etc.\u2014are ignored and any harm that comes to the collection of cells sitting in a womb is legally the mother\u2019s fault.
\nAlong these lines, because the miscarriage or stillbirth is a \u201cperson,\u201d and therefore subject to laws that make a crime out of \u201cconcealing\u201d dead bodies, a situation <\/a><\/span>is created in which \u201ca person could potentially be arrested for waiting even one minute to call the authorities after a pregnancy loss.\u201d
\nEven worse, fetal personhood laws put the life of pregnant people in very real danger. Miscarriages and stillbirths can require immediate medical attention at the risk of death or serious injury. Fearing that some possible action taken while pregnant can lead to their arrest, criminalizing pregnancy means that the person who just miscarried\u2014already a potentially traumatic experience\u2014may be less likely to go to a doctor. In the dozens of states where abortion access is severely restricted, even if they do get help, it can be severely constrained because of similarities in practices between having a safe miscarriage and abortion.
\nReferencing a number of studies, a Kaiser Family Foundation report<\/span><\/a> states, \u201cAlmost all of the methods used to manage miscarriages and stillbirths are identical to those used in therapeutic abortions. Therefore, the clinical training necessary to safely manage a patient experiencing a pregnancy loss is very similar to that needed to perform abortions. As such, medical residents at religiously affiliated hospitals or in states with restrictive abortion laws may struggle to obtain the necessary training and caseload to become proficient in these skills \u2026 When miscarriages present in emergency settings with significant bleeding or infection, it is imperative the clinician has the skills to promptly and safely treat that individual. Little to no training in abortion care may negatively affect providers\u2019 ability to safely manage pregnancy loss.\u201d
\nRacism and reproductive restrictions<\/strong>
\nCriminalizing pregnancy shifts the blame of hugely disproportionate miscarriage and stillbirth rates from the racist and destructive economic system to individual actions by oppressed people. As Ava B writes for Planned Parenthood of Arizona, \u201cBlack, Latinx, and Native American women have higher rates of miscarriage and stillbirth than non-Hispanic white women, with Black people having the highest rates of stillbirth. This disparity can be due to a number of reasons, mostly that people of color tend to have lower rates of access to necessary prenatal care.\u201d
\nThese are also the communities most at risk for being arrested for \u201cfetal homicide\u201d and similar charges. Since the 1980s there has been an offensive against pregnant people of color encapsulated by the term \u201ccrack babies.\u201d A whole universe of pseudo-scientific articles has been used to massively expand the prison industrial complex on the backs of Black and Brown mothers.
\nThe New York Times<\/em> editorial board summed up this earlier period: \u201cThe appetite for stories of black depravity extended to medical journals, which favored shoddy studies showing that cocaine harmed babies over better research refuting that claim. Eugenicists who had long sought justification for sterilizing African-American women found some affirmation for that view when, in 1989, The Washington Post<\/em> opinion writer Charles Krauthammer noted in a widely syndicated column that black women were spawning \u2018a bio-underclass\u2019 of impaired children \u2018whose biological inferiority is stamped at birth.\u2019 This disability was said to be \u2018irrevocable.\u2019 Mr. Krauthammer went on to say that \u2018the dead babies may be the lucky ones.\u2019\u201d
\nThat same embrace of moralism over scientific reality continues today. Brittney Poolaw, whose story opens this article, admitted to methamphetamine use when she spoke with medical professionals following her miscarriage. Yet, Oxygen Crime News reports<\/span><\/a> that \u201cat Poolaw\u2019s one-day trial \u2026 the jury was presented with evidence by prosecutors that there was no way to state with certainty that her drug use caused her miscarriage, and both the nurse and the medical examiner noted the fetal abnormalities seen at the autopsy. \u2026 The jury convicted her in under three hours. She was sentenced to four years in prison.\u201d
\nThat article also references a study by the Journal of Addiction Medicine<\/em>, which states, \u201cNo consistent teratological effects of in utero [methamphetamine] exposure on the developing human fetus have been identified\u201d and that, in other studies of drug use during pregnancy \u201cthe effects of poverty, poor diet, and tobacco use \u2026 have been shown to be as harmful or more harmful than the drug use itself.\u201d
\nEnd criminalization of pregnancy; legalize abortion!<\/strong>
\nThe criminalization of pregnancy and the deepening attack on abortion rights are two sides of the offensive against reproductive autonomy in the United States. They combine to create a situation where abortion access is virtually impossible for a huge number of working people in this country and a disproportionate number of people of color. In that context, people are driven to dangerous \u201cunderground\u201d methods that put themselves in danger. Worse, if there are any problems requiring medical attention, the person seeking an abortion can face criminal charges.
\nEven in cases where an abortion is not attempted but just contemplated, the state can bring charges. This is exactly what happened to Purvi Patel, who had a stillbirth in 2013 and was convicted for \u201cfeticide and neglect of a dependent.\u201d Part of the legal case against Patel was the unproven and dubious claim that the fetus was alive when it was born. The other factor was the prosecutor\u2019s claim that she had purchased abortion-inducing drugs online, despite the fact that there was no indication of their use in a toxicology report of the fetus.
\nWorkers\u2019 organizations need to fight for expanding natal care access and free abortion on demand, instead of expanding restrictions and surveillance on pregnant people. As long as capitalism remains the mode of production governing all aspects of social and personal life, even these basic democratic demands can not be met. Facing spiraling crises bringing down the quality of life for working people in all sectors, capitalism\u2019s go-to \u201csolutions\u201d are almost always carceral, affecting the most oppressed first and foremost.
\nThis needs to be directly confronted at every turn. What is necessary to win real reproductive justice\u2014which includes nationalizing housing and land, aggressively combating the climate crisis, and providing free 24\/7 child and elder care for all\u2014is a fighting organization of the working class. The perspective of this organization must wbe to build the largest possible mobilizations around every demand and manifestation of struggle through coalitions that are independent of the capitalists and their state. Ultimately, the only way to permanently turn back the attacks on reproductive rights is to smash the capitalist domination of society and the state that upholds them and for working people to actively construct the new society based on collectivity and solidarity.
\nIllustration: http:\/\/www.freedigitalphotos.net<\/span><\/a><\/em><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

Brittney Poolaw, a 21-year-old Indigenous woman, is the most recent high-profile victim of anti-women reproductive policies in the United States. In October, Poolaw was convicted by the state of Oklahoma on charges of first-degree manslaughter with a sentence of four years in prison. The \u201ccrime\u201d was having a miscarriage in her fourth month of pregnancy at the age of 19 in January 2020. According to Oxygen News, 57 women have been arrested for miscarriage in Oklahoma and over 1200 in the United States since 2006.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":13882120,"featured_media":11679,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_crdt_document":"","_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":false,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2},"_wpas_customize_per_network":false,"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[27799],"tags":[27712,30612,28148,30613,27714,30408],"class_list":["post-11678","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-national","tag-abortion","tag-miscarriages","tag-racism","tag-reproductive-restrictions","tag-reproductive-rights","tag-womens-rights"],"translation":{"provider":"WPGlobus","version":"3.0.2","language":"es","enabled_languages":["en","es"],"languages":{"en":{"title":true,"content":true,"excerpt":true},"es":{"title":false,"content":false,"excerpt":false}}},"aioseo_notices":[],"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_likes_enabled":true,"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_shortlink":"https:\/\/wp.me\/pdQxqk-32m","amp_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/11678","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/13882120"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=11678"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/11678\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=11678"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=11678"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/workersvoiceus.org\/es\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=11678"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}